Skip navigation

WATCH: Inaugural Lecture: Professor Carole McCartney, Northumbria Law School



The Forensic Science Paradox

Those among us with an interest in forensic science or wrongful convictions, fictional or otherwise, do not struggle for entertainment. Indeed, our interests can often be catered for in the very same TV series or movie, with forensic science having become indelibly linked with wrongful convictions.

One can never be sure however, whether the forensic scientist is going to be the antagonist, or ally. Such dualism poses a challenge to researchers and reformers. Should forensic science be encouraged as a powerful antidote to wrongful convictions, or would the safer policy be to leave the ‘CSI’ kit at home and avoid potential injustice? 

This lecture will explain this ‘forensic science paradox’: as cause and cure of wrongful convictions, and suggest solutions to mitigate the risks posed by reliance upon forensic science.

About the Speaker 

Carole McCartney is a Professor in the School of Law, Northumbria University. Previously senior lecturer in criminal law and criminal justice at the University of Leeds, and Bond University, Queensland, Australia. Carole has written on Australian justice, Innocence Projects, miscarriages of justice, policing cooperation, and DNA, forensic science and criminal justice more widely. She established an Innocence Project at the University of Leeds in 2005, and was project manager for the Nuffield Council on Bioethics report ‘The Forensic Uses of Bio-information: Ethical Issues’ and the Nuffield Foundation project ‘The Future of Forensic Bioinformation. She completed an EU Marie Curie international research fellowship (2009-2012) on ‘Forensic Identification Frontiers’.  She continues to work on projects around forensic science and miscarriages of justice, biometrics, and science and justice.

Read more on Carole's staff profile here

To register your attendance, please complete the form below. For queries email

Event Details



a sign in front of a crowd

Northumbria Open Days

Open Days are a great way for you to get a feel of the University, the city of Newcastle upon Tyne and the course(s) you are interested in.

Research at Northumbria

Research at Northumbria

Research is the life blood of a University and at Northumbria University we pride ourselves on research that makes a difference; research that has application and affects people's lives.

a person sitting at a table

Order your prospectus

If you would like to know more about our courses, or life in general as a student at Northumbria, then we can help you.

Latest News and Features

MFA student Celia Burbush, MFA co-Programme Leader Gavin Butt and Deputy Head of Arts, Steve Gilroy, are pictured outside the new look Gallery North.
Minister for Science, Research and Innovation opens £2m investment in region’s Engineering and Environment students
REF 2021
Professor Andrew Wathey CBE speaking at the Rutherford Roundtable
Sarah Munro, Director of BALTIC Centre for Contemporary Art stood next to Professor Katy Shaw, Director of Cultural Partnerships at Northumbria University, in front of The Travelling Gallery bus in the Quad on Northumbria University's campus.
Dr Matteo Sommacal
MoS Ford aerospace
Mohamed Badar

Back to top